| The
June 30, 1997 issue of Computerworld included a fascinating article
on staffing issues for Information Technology organizations. No
one reading this needs to be told that it is increasingly difficult
to attract, hire and retain quality technical staff: That has become
a core reality in this industry. What was interesting about the
Computerworld article was that it forecasts the duration of the
current 'talent gap', and also estimates the costs to industry that
result. In this article, we present Terrapin's views on IT staffing
issues, and propose some solutions.
First, some rather compelling numbers from the Computerworld article:
- The IT talent gap will continue for at least six to ten years
- The IT talent gap will cost as much as $15 billion per year
in higher compensation costs
- The IT talent gap will cost as much as $500 billion per
year in lost revenue
The underlying causes are simple enough: Demand for technical talent
is vastly outstripping the supply. Recent reports have estimated that
US industry is generating on the order of 100,000 new IT positions
annually. Furthermore, US colleges and universities are graduating
approximately 30,000 Computer Science graduates annually. The numbers
speak for themselves.
So, what are we supposed to do about this? The solutions you read
about most often have a common theme: do a better job recruiting.
Ideas include referral bonus programs, retention programs, programs
to identify non-traditional recruits, etc.
At Terrapin, we categorize all of these as the "better bait"
strategy. We point out that all companies are fishing from the same
pond when it comes to recruiting technical talent. It certainly
helps to have the best bait, but doing so does not guarantee that
the fish are going to bite. And in the case of recruiting technical
talent, good bait can take the form of extremely high salary offers,
even for relatively inexperienced individuals. Less experience increases
risk for your business.
In the final analysis, absent some obvious defect in their existing
recruiting strategy, we think most companies already have about
as good a staff as they are going to be able to hire in this market.
The myriad factors that draw employee and employer together have
already been set in place. There is little that a company can do
to change their current position in the talent market.
This is where Terrapin comes in. Knowing that you have as good
a staff as you are likely to hire is of scant consolation when you
are faced with a software development organization that is not up
to the challenges imposed by your overall business conditions. An
alternative way of improving the performance of your software development
organization that is not based simply on hiring more and better
staff is needed. At Terrapin, we believe that process improvement
is key to accomplishing this objective.
One of the core principles of process improvement is to reduce
the dependence of the organization on highly talented individuals.
Instead, the organization learns how to deliver remarkable results
with the average talent level that it already has. In other
words, process improvement can help ordinary people do extraordinary
things.
From another perspective, process improvement allows you to utilize
the intellectual capital you are already paying for in the
most effective possible way. Our strategy does not rely on making
your employees smarter or better individually. Instead, we reduce
the internal 'organizational friction' that slows your people down.
Through the development of processes and discipline, we help organizations
to become smarter. This focus on the organization rather than
individuals helps your business leverage existing intellectual capital,
and to acquire new intellectual capital. Paradoxically, this
focus on the organization leads to more effective development of
individual members of the staff. This results from sharpened definition
of roles, accountabilities, objectives. Targeting the organization
for improvement increases the capacity of both individuals and the
organization!
We can go on with further examples, but the point is clear: When
confronted with today's recruiting market, Information Technology
organizations can either try to recruit better or work smarter.
Our experience tells us that working smarter through process improvement
is faster, easier and much more economical.
|